Recent Articles Jul. 22 - Today’s Vintages Pinot Noir Release ~ Miguel Torres 2004 Mas Borras Triumphs! Jul. 15 - Ontario Winery Destinations ~ From the Best of Apple to the Finest of Grapes Jul. 8 - Discovering Alsace ~ Challenges in Buying the Best ~ Part I Jul. 1 - Canada Day's Top Ten, Eh - The Endless Search Jul. 1 - The Top Ten Canadian Wineries Jun. 24 - Best New Releases for Discerning Palates Jun. 17 - The World Cup of Sauvignon Blanc ~ Austria Triumphant Jun. 10 - Buy it in Alberta & Bring it home to Daddy! Jun. 3 - Thinking Pink - A Rosé for Every Taste May. 27 - Vintage Plays Havoc with Classic Contenders ~ A Delicious Knockout for 2002 Ornellaia May. 20 - New Zealand's Explosion of Flavours ~ Will give your Victoria Day long weekend a lift May. 6 - When it comes to wine lists ~ Bigger isn't necessarily better Apr.
29 - The Top Shelf Apr. 29 - A Hole-in-One Twice for Greg Norman ~ Wedding Bell Bubblies Apr. 22 - Gambling on Wine Dinners ~ Three recent positive outings Apr.
15 - The Top Shelf Apr. 15 - Putting a little "hop" into your Easter brunch Apr. 8 - A Survivor's Guide to the 2006 California Wine Fair Apr.
1 - The Top Shelf Apr. 1 - Waking Up & Smelling the Flowers ~ A Bouquet of Springtime Whites ~ All Under $20 Mar.
25 - The Top Shelf Mar. 25 - Tracking Down Vintages Best Buys Mar. 11 - Ireland: The cradle of Whiskey Mar. 4 - The Best of Today's Vintages Release ~ South Africa's Answer to Tequila Feb. 25 - Mining for Gold in South Africa ~ Great Pinotage & Shiraz Feb. 18 - Going for Gold at Vintages Feb. 11 - Beware of great wine reviews that don't deliver ~ Is it me, the critic or the bottle? Feb. 4 - Spanish Wines Take Flight Jan. 28 - D-Day at Vintages 724 ~ Vintages items go on sale today! Jan. 14 - Ontario's Icewines Shine ~ The Icewine Oscars for the Best 2004 Jan. 7 - A Quality Vintages Kick-off to the New Year Easy Quaffing Southern Hemisphere Shiraz Dec. 31 - Cognac Unconquered ~ From $1.30 to $74.88 an ounce ~ Sipping Your Way into the New Year Dec. 24 - LCBO Gifts ~ Buy Carefully ~ Juicy cherry & tangy cranberry flavours for your Turkey Dec. 10 - Great Holiday Wines in Today's Vintages release ~ From the Bargains to the Jewels Dec. 3 - From the Perfect Pear Martini ~ to a Vintage Port to Remember Nov. 26 - Wines to Buy & Wines to Avoid Nov. 19 - Beaujolais Nouveau Celebrates 54 Years Nov. 12 - Vintages Release Best Buys ~ From California to Bordeaux Nov. 5 - "Eyes Wide Shut" ~ Taste, texture and scent in motion Oct. 29 - Tricks & Treats in Today's Vintages Release ~ Some Awesome Aussi Highlights Oct. 22 - Perfect Fall Libations ~ Obscure varieties from Welschriesling to Semillon Oct. 15 - Hop Scotch ~ The biggest whisky release on record Oct. 8 - A Toast to the Turkey ~ Many whites, some reds and even a sparkling rosé |
In
Homage to Cabernet Sauvignon LIVE
WINE LINK Today's Vintages' "Born to be King" release is supposed to be a celebration of Cabernet Sauvignon It features 29 reds, many of them blends, from ten countries. Widely regarded as the world's greatest red grape variety, Cabernet Sauvignon's acknowledged home and claim to fame is Bordeaux. Given this fact, it is ironic that there is nary a French product is to be seen on the Vintages' Catalogue cover, nor for that matter, on the inside jackets, which are festooned with new world Cab. Making matters worse, only one of the three-featured Bordeaux wines being released today has a majority of Cabernet Sauvignon! The still youthful and well-structured 2001 Chateau d'Issan (683672) at $61.95, however, is most impressive. This third growth Margaux comes with 30% Merlot. It is solid and fairly extracty with lime purée and lingering, plumy, cassis, dried ripe cherry flavours. It is something that could be drunk today (if decanted well in advance), but will definitely be better in the future, perhaps three years from now. I also liked the 2001 Chateau Roland-La-Garde (674234) at $19.95, but this Premières Côtes de Blaye on the right bank of the Gironde River is apparently 77% Merlot with only 20% Cabernet Sauvignon and 3% Malbec. It is ready to enjoy with harmonious, tangy plum and sandalwood flavours and a slightly dusty, leathery finish. Sadly, the other three French reds didn't make it to my short list. In fact, only a handful did! In the easy-to-drink, well-priced department, the repeat shipment of the estate-grown Catena Zapata 2004 Alamos Cabernet Sauvignon (467944) at a modest $13.95 is a definite hit. Originating in Argentina's Mendoza region, it has dry, smooth, juicy, plumy-cherry flavours with a long lingering finish. Perfect for drinking today. From Spain's Penedes region, the Vintages Essential Miguel Torres 2001 Gran Coronas Cabernet Sauvignon (36483) shines at $17.95. This blend of 85% Cabernet Sauvignon and 15% Tempranillo is quite firm and well structured with slightly spicy, intense, ripe plum and chocolate-cranberry fruit flavours. A big red, which can be enjoyed today, but will keep for several years. Another fruit-driven solid red, this time from Chile, also hit the mark. Perhaps Marques de Casa Concha 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon (337238) has a bit more in common with Bordeaux. It is very dry and extracty with burley, spice-tinged, plumy and dried cherry flavours. Note that the Vintages Catalogue tells us that it costs $17.95 - in fact, it is $18.95. Slowly moving up the price chain, Frescobaldi 2004 Tenuta di Castiglioni Cabernet Sauvignon/Sangiovese (974394) at $19.95 represented decent drinking value. It is quite accessible with harmonious, spicy, ripe plum and dried cherry flavours and a vanilla tinged finish. Note that this is 2004, not 2003 as mentioned in the Catalogue. Next up is South Australia's Coonawarra Leconfield 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon (441501) at $29.95. It is very dry, solid and Bordeaux-like on the palate with slightly peppery, garrigue-tinged, dried ripe plum flavours with lime-tinged, cedary, chocolate notes on the finish. It also needs time to evolve - two years Finally, moving on to California, I had hoped to find a real Bordeaux challenge. Alas, only the Napa Valley Cain 2002 Concept (590299) at $73.95 gave Chateau d'Issan a run for the money. This blend of 84% Cabernet Sauvignon, 7% Cabernet Franc, 5 % Petit Verdot and 4% Merlot has an extremely deep intense purple colour and youthful, intense, ripe plum nose. On the palate it is harmonious and medium-full bodied with ripe plum and mocha flavours followed up by a lingering finish. It is certainly much better than the previously released earthy 2000 vintage. Proving anything can happen; a second bottle of 2002 was corked. Talking about California, at a recent blind tasting I previewed 19 California Cabs being featured at upcoming April 10th California Wine Fair. Perhaps I was tired, but I was unmoved by even the most expensive entry: Heitz 2001 Martha's Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon at $225. In fact, one well-respected critic awarded it a meager 86 points. It reminded me of what Time Magazine called the "Judgement in Paris" which was a blind tasting organized 30 years ago on May 24, 1976 by Steven Spurrier at his L'Acadamie du Vin Parisian wine school. Well-known French professionals attended the tasting, which pitted six California Cabs against four top Bordeaux. Apparently none of the wines being tasted were revealed prior to the event. The French were humiliated - California, and in particular Stag's Leap 1973 Cabernet Sauvignon, emerged victorious. A short time later, I mounted a similar more comprehensive comparative blind tasting here in Toronto as national wine columnist for the Financial Times of Canada. One of the additional wines I included was 1970 Beaulieu Vineyard Georges de Latour Private Reserve Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon. It won hand's down, with California's '71 Ridge Montebello and '68 Heitz coming in second and third respectively. Readers can see my original article by clicking here and the American response by San Francisco Chronicle winewriter Hank Rubin by clicking here The positive thing about such comparative blind tastings is that they can highlight winemaking achievements around the world. The serious weakness, however, is that the "winners" are based on a short and often arbitrary list of competitors. Many great wines are omitted. For instance, 1970 Beaulieu Vineyard Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon, 1970 Chateau Latour and 1968 Heitz were not included in the original Spurrier tasting. Nor were the tasters tested and the tasting results statistically scrutinized before being released. There was no accounting for any possible marginally defective bottles. There were no repeat tastings to check consistency of the bottles and/or the tasters. Given these considerations, it would be ludicrous to suggest that either Spurrier's "winner" (1973 Stag's Leap) or my top wine (1970 BV Private Reserve) is "the best" of what was produced. Rather, these fine wines simply turned out to be the winners in a small, but significant, sample at one moment in time. Let me note that a detailed statistical analysis of Spurrier's results by Orley Ashenfelter and Richard E. Quandt reveals that the ranking, which was done by a simple averaging the scores out of 20 is flawed. In fact, there is no statistical difference between the two top wines: Stag's Leap 1973 and the real second place wine, which should have been 1970 Chateau Montrose. It seems that 1970 Chateau Mouton Rothschild, under more appropriate statistical scoring procedures, would have ranked third making it appear in the not far behind in the group of secondary choices. How many readers knew that Spurrier, who had prior knowledge of the wines being tasted (although not the order), tied his top four wines with 14 out of 20 points? Or that his lowest score of 8 points went to the fourth place wine 1970 Chateau Haut Brion? To see the statistical analysis click here To address the French complaint that California wines won't keep; I also organized a comparative tasting of eight top wines from 1945 to 1949. Once again, legendary winemaker/enologist Andre Tchelistcheff's 1947 Beaulieu Vineyard Private Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon placed first, followed very closely by 1947 Chateau Latour. There was no statistical difference between these two top wines. It dispelled the myth about longevity and proved that truly great wines, new world or old world, can live for decades. Following up on this longevity point, I recently revisited 1970 BV Private Reserve. Unannounced, I slipped a bottle into a tasting last Sunday night with a small group of serious wine fans. The blind consensus: the mystery wine was great - probably a classic, first-growth Bordeaux. When I revealed that it was a 1970, Alan Gardner, President of the Toronto Winetasters Society, hit the nail on the head by guessing that it was 1970 BV Private Reserve. He added that this was one of his top-four lifetime, 100-point reds, which must be tasted at least twice. And while this particular bottle was by all means superb, Gardner felt that it had slipped a bit due to aging from 20 out of 20 points, to the 19 point range. Keeping in mind that this bottle has rested undisturbed for over 30 years at a dark chilly 4° C, who knows how the next bottle of BV 1970 will show? While great wines can live for decades, the bottom line is that when it comes to enjoying it, timing is everything. National Post readers wishing to receive the current March 2006 Vintage Assessments newsletter, which covers today's Vintages release, as well as March 4th (including exclusive current ISD reviews) along with Michael Vaughan's Summary Release Buying Guides can have it e-mailed today and receive a $20 discount - click here. 2001-2002-2003-2004-2005
Tasting Note Database To
use our Tasting
Notes Database: click
here
Copyright Food & Beverage Testing Institute of Canada
2006 |