Copper Grill has high hopes of making High Park east trendy food territory

Review by Michael Vaughan

Any reviewer knows it's easier to pan than to praise -- and it's infinitely more fun. So why on my first disappointing visit to the Copper Grill did I refuse to review it? I didn't have the stomach to help destroy it.

You have to understand: Roncesvalles has never been a culinary destination. Yes, it's true that the Pope made a pitstop to the long since boarded up Sir Nicholas Restaurant for some Polish/Hungarian cuisine. And, yes, there was the brief meteoric rise of an Italian bistro, Pichii's, where people would actually line up for Paul's culinary art. But, unfortunately, this charming area is still known as a street where you a can find a cinema, a funeral home, and a full plate of Chinese food for four bucks and change.

Thus, when Penny Young decided to open this upscale establishment, it was a brave move. She saved enough from the sale of her Second Cup franchise to open up where few restaurateurs have dared. With no formal training, Young, who owns the building and lives above the restaurant, sees Copper Grill as a catalyst for change, attracting young professionals to the new and trendy east side of High Park. I hope she's right.

I'm happy to discover the original chef along with his offending dishes is a thing of the past; he lasted a mere two weeks. Better yet, prices have dipped dramatically.

Large sidewalk windows flood the attractively lit, small, modern room. Denis, our waiter, obligingly closes the windows, helping us to warm our chilly bods on this cold fall night. Water and three different breads a la Fred appear: a bitter, brown bread, olive-infused white, and, best of all, a plain baguette slice.

I'm tempted by the soup of the day ($3.50), a dazzling, dense, viscous, purée of fresh sweet potato with just the right spicing. I then wade into a broad white dish of perfectly cooked just-pink sautéed chicken livers with spinach, garlic and shallots in a delicious bourbon demi-glace reduction served with puff pastry and a mound of thin crispy red onions ($7.50). In one word, the pumpkin gnocchi ($7) are wow. Although nickel-sized, it's firm and extremely tasty, and the sun-dried tomato/chipotle cream sauce tangos with tang. A baker's dozen disappear in a nanosecond -- so does the sauce.

The grilled portobello mushroom with arugula, radicchio, roasted sweet pepper and baby grape tomatoes, tossed in extra-virgin olive oil with shaved asiago ($8.50) is another winner. Its slightly crusty, tender, warm mushrooms come garnished with a delicious combo of greens and dressing. (A glass of fresh, crisp, dry, apple-melon flavoured Cave Springs VQA Ontario Dry Riesling ($6/glass $24/bottle) works well with both openers. The ever-changing wine list features 19 wines, 10 by the glass in the $6 to $8 range. For apres diner, there are a variety of ports, dessert wines and special spirits like a Delaforce Paramount tawny, $5.50.)

This may be executive chef Brad Krawchuk's first solo gig, but he certainly has a firm grip on his sauces. Krawchuk spent several years in kitchens on the West Coast, six months in Italy on a special George Brown culinary program, and, most recently, two years at Mildred Pierce with Claire Stubbs. Sous chef Ryan Klauke, who solos Sunday and Monday, seems perfectly comfortable behind the stove.

After this auspicious start, we proceed to select from eight mains, priced from $13 to $21. The roast duck breast ($17.50) au jus with Cointreau and sun-dried cherries is served with roasted new potatoes and sautéed seasonal vegetables. The seven, albeit small, slices of tender and tasty duck come on a plate so hot you could fry an egg. The problem is it keeps on cooking; when I get down to the last slice, it's overdone. The sweet spirit-infused sauce is quite sublime, as is the veggie, a nicely prepared melange of roasted potatoes with flavourful zucchini, green beans and slivers of red pepper -- all topped by a big sprig of fresh rosemary. (Note: unfortunately this dish didn't make the cut on the new menu.)

A daily fresh fish of the day is available, yet conspicuously absent from the menu. Krawchuk does good work with fish. We settle for his pan-seared sea bass ($20) with a roasted pepper coulis, crispy sweet potato, sauté of spinach, green beans and oyster mushrooms. The surprisingly ample portion is perfectly cooked and served skin-on -- probably the finest to grace the area. I most enjoy the sweet coulis with fish flesh contrast.

For dessert (all six are $6) we give in to a flourless chocolate espresso torte with a berry coulis -- more like two small slices of a very dense, sweet, moist truffle cake. Thumbs up. A new item on the fall menu worth exploring is a surprisingly thin "low-rise" sweet maple pumpkin pecan pie served with a tangy cranberry coulis and superbly rich vanilla ice cream.

Young has had her hands full with what was a very shaky June start. In all, I visit this place three times, and with each she's risen to the challenge: she has reduced prices, brought in a new culinary team, and come up with a credible menu. And while portions tend to be on the modest size, customers should be pleased with above-average quality. Copper Grill is a welcome breath of fresh air and may well become a new east side High Park destination.

Copper Grill
390 Roncesvalles Ave.
(416) 533-1442


click here for larger image

SAUCES SUPREME: This may be executive chef Brad Krawchuk's first solo gig, but he certainly has a firm grip on his sauces.

Review Archive

Click for an explanation of our ratings

Photo by Marijke Leupen
Designed and produced by Karen Ahmed

Published October 8, 1999