Vintage Assessments Home Page

Recent Articles

Archive of National Post Articles

Sign-up Now!

Get all the evaluations for the April  Release
Subscribe to Vintage Assessments today by Clicking Here
This not-for-profit website is dedicated to the discerning reader!

Winemaker’s Dinners
A Survivor’s Guide

© Michael Vaughan 2003
National Post Weekly Wine & Spirits Columnist
 Saturday, March 15, 2003

It starts next week, the rising tide of chi-chi Spring winemaker’s dinners. They sprout up like daffodils and certainly have their allure. Timing has a lot to do with travel schedules and the impetus is this month’s renowned Vancouver Playhouse where 100+ winemakers are going to be in attendance.

The suggestion of a winemaker’s dinner sound great – after all, how many opportunities does one get to actually sit down with a winemaker? Unfortunately, there are wide variances in the quality of such events. The key things to consider are: what wines are being served, where is it being organized, how good is the menu/kitchen, how many people are attending and, last but not least, the price.

One thing I have learned is that the larger the group, the less likely that the event will excel. Certainly the window to meet and greet the winemaker becomes diluted. In addition, it becomes much more challenging for a kitchen, even with a great chef, to cut the culinary mustard when having to produce food for the masses.

Last fall, for instance, I published complaints from readers who had attended a winemaker’s dinner I had written about. In this case, it was not the food, nor the venue, but rather the Canadian agent’s selection of wines that left much to be desired for the $125 price tag.

Well guess what, someone was listening. In this case, the folks at Epic Restaurant at Fairmont’s Royal York Hotel, who host a number of such events a year, took the unprecedented step of organizing a professional pre-tasting for their upcoming Tuesday, March 18th Joseph Phelps Napa Valley “Winemaker’s” Dinner.

While some half-dozen food, restaurant and wine writers were invited to attend, I was the only member of the fifth estate to show up. Who knows why the others didn’t appear. Whatever, sitting at the kitchen roundtable with the chefs, wine reps and key food and beverage managers was a most fruitful exercise.

The pretasting made me conscious that selecting the most appropriate dish to accompany a wine isn’t always a cakewalk. Take Phelps 2001 Sauvignon Blanc ($38.87 consignment as priced by Lifford Agencies). The choice was between a Woolwich goat cheese appetizer and a peppercorn crusted ostrich carpaccio accompanied by some cheese shaped into a flower. Initially, my intuition was to vote for the goat cheese – a perky marriage that has worked wonders with classic Loire Sancerre Sauvignon Blanc. But not today! Believe it or not, the thin slice of ostrich carpaccio accompanied by Quebec-inspired Tete de Moine (or “head of the monk”) - a nutty, rich, Swiss Alps cows’ milk cheese, won hands down.

And so it went, course after course being married with just the right dish. Lobster and halibut for the Phelps 2000 Los Carneros Chardonnay ($55.40). For the main course, we worked our way through three reds and four meat dishes. Two excelled; and so we have a duo of Muscovy duck breast with black currant essence on one side of the plate and venison with seared Quebec foie gras in a dark chocolate sauce on the other side. We kept the Phelps 2000 Cabernet Sauvignon ($88.45) and Syrah-based Phelps 2000 Le Mistral and put the rare 1999 Insignia (estimated at $200) by itself with the Quebec cheese course. To accompany dessert, we have the botrytised Sauternes styled 1997 Delice du Semillon, which is virtually unobtainable!

Five courses, seven if you include the hors d’oeuvres and granité, and eight wines later, the menu was done. Bottom line, barring any catastrophe like corked wines, this event should be a smashing success. You can check out the final menu on my website ($125 exclusive of taxes/gratuities) or call 416-860-6949. The only drawback is that only 55 seats are available and that winemaker Craig Williams will not be attendance. But affable Kathleen Kazan Dirickson, a knowledgeable 10-year Phelps winery veteran, will. Also making its debut is Phelps 2002 Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Made on the 4.5 acre Spring Valley Napa ranch, this stone mill cold pressed elixir will appear with the carpaccio. Only 36 cases of 12-ounce bottles were produced on March 2002.   

Those are unable to attend might want to take advantage of a real deal to taste the Phelps 1998 Insignia ($160 Classics 2001 Catalogue). Until this Monday, March 17th, Epic Restaurant will be pouring it for only $9 an ounce, about half of what it goes for in NYC. On the same day, we have Napa Valley Vintners Association Trade-Only Tasting, which runs from 3:00 p.m. – 5:30 pm (information is posted on my website). Unfortunately, no public tasting is planned for this year. Sommeliers and trade readers can call Paula Oreskovich at Praxis Public Relations at 905-949-8255 ext. 223.

In contrast, on Wednesday, March 19, the LCBO is holding a public-only Burgundy Pre-Arrival Tasting featuring 67 wines from the 2001 vintage (152 Burgundies being offered). This year Vintages dropped both the afternoon trade-only and Ottawa tastings meaning that restaurateurs will simply be out of luck in trying to figure out which wines to buy. In addition, for the first time Vintages decided not to invite any wine writers to preview these wines all of which were donated by the participating producers. Vintages Purchasing Manager Claudius Fehr states that if you “can’t make the tasting on the 19th  - don’t worry – you can always check out your favourite third-party sources and order between March 20 and March 28.” What “favourite third-party sources” could he be thinking of? To my knowledge, not a single Ontario wine writer has tasted these wines. I have also have been informed that Vintages refused to sample many of the wines that agents were anxious to pour, despite the fact that these Burgundies are donated at no cost to the LCBO. At the time of writing, some 14 spots were left at $65 per person (it is now sold-out). It takes place at the Arcadian Court (Simpson Tower, 8th floor) from 6:30 pm to 9:00 pm.

Finally, a word on the upcoming Dinner with D’Arenberg beware! An invitation for this March 31, 2003 event is being extended to VINTAGES V-MAIL subscribers at a jaw-dropping $140.00 per person. It all takes place at the Courthouse Market Grille on Adelaide Street East, which to the best of my knowledge (and experience) has never excelled as a culinary destination, especially with 120 in attendance. Worse yet, I have now had a chance to taste some of the wines being featured (8 are appearing in Vintages on April 5th) and, unfortunately, I am not impressed. 2001 Olive Grove Chardonnay ($14.95) is a commercial tropical fruit bomb and disappointing when compared to the far superior 1999; 2002 Dry Dam Riesling (($14.95) is extremely dry and crisp. Perhaps the dinner wines will be better: 1994 Barrel Fermented Chardonnay; 1992 D’Arry’s Original Shiraz/Grenache; 1996 Dead Arm Shiraz; 2000 Vintage Fortified Shiraz ($16.95 per 375 ml). May I suggest you save your $140 for another day.

 

Vintages April 2003 Release
To see the complete list of upcoming products click here
(sorted by date of release). It includes the number of cases, which wines were presented by the LCBO, our agent ID for every product, as well as, special unannounced In Store Discoveries” for March.
You can also see it sorted by agent
click here  

 

Check out the
March 2003 InStore Discovery


Subscribe to Vintage Assessments Today
Click Here

 

Copyright Food & Beverage Testing Institute of Canada 2004
Prior written permission is required for any form of reproduction
 (electronic or other wise) and or quotation.
Contact Michael Vaughan at
mbv@total.net