Vintage Assessments Home Page

Latest National Post Articles

Archive of National Post Articles

Sign-up Now!

Get all the evaluations for the MAY  Release
Subscribe to Vintage Assessments today by Clicking Here
This not-for-profit website is dedicated to the discerning reader!

Terrific wines to Discover
At this weekend’s Toronto Wine & Cheese Show

© Michael Vaughan 2003
National Post Weekly Wine & Spirits Columnist
 Saturday, April 12, 2003

I am standing on the 29th floor of the Fairmont Royal York Hotel at a preview tasting of the 34 gold medal winners featured at this weekend’s Toronto Wine & Cheese Show. “How did you come up with this selection?” asks one invitee pointing to the under $13 reds. He adds that he prefers the slightly sweeter, fruitier Australian Shiraz to the dried, but better structured South African Shiraz. Ironically, the next person much prefers the latter. 

Fortunately, it’s not a matter of being right or wrong, it’s all a matter of taste. Both reds are clearly gold medal winners! Professional wine judges, however, tend to look at the technical side of things as opposed to casual sippers who simply either like or dislike a wine’s flavour. Things like the structure, length and finish will be less important to those just trying to find something that’s worth drinking.

And that’s what this weekend’s show is all about – discovering wines YOU like. That and actually being able to buy the winners, all of which are available for sale at the LCBO, at the winery store or through the agent.

Of course, some are a tad more idiosyncratic than others. Everyone is certain to enjoy a bubbly glass of Spain’s Codorniu Brut Clasico, which is bargain-priced at only $10.50. Moving on to the only gold medal winning dry aperitif, not everyone is going to faint with joy over Alvear’s Fino Montilla, which is the incredibly priced at $8.60. This Sherry-inspired preprandial is bit of an acquired taste, but when served well chilled, its bracingly dry, slightly nutty, dried lemon flavours make tapas and other hors d’oeuvres come alive.

It’s sad but true that most restaurants refuse to even acknowledge that these everyday LCBO wines exist. The reason is simple, it’s hard for a licensee to make a big buck with inexpensive General List products that many know and love. In fact, a majority would rather take a $10 mystery wine and hustle it out the door for $40+! And yet, how many times have I ordered a seriously overpriced, private import “unknown” which turns out to be a taste dud? It seems that many licensees don’t want to hear that today’s best of show red, 2001 Bellingham Coastal Shiraz a South African gem at only $12.65, tastes better than 80% of the reds on their wine list.

While I admire licensee efforts aimed at getting well-priced unsung heroes on their wine lists, there is way too much “me-tooism” out there - if it’s at so-and-so’s restaurant then we need to have it too! In addition, there is little if any wine missionary work out there. I am referring to fruit wines, which are simply not taken seriously. And yet, dollars for donuts, if one compares a good fruit wine and icewine (costing four times the price) side by side, many would prefer Mr. Fruit!

And this is where the Toronto Wine & Cheese show excels with a record-setting ten gold medals for fruit wines. There are about one hundred fruit wines to discover at the show, including 39 award winners. Black currant seems to be the fruit flavour of the month with the newly opened Downey’s Estate 2002 Black Currant ($14.95) won best off-dry fruit wine and Harvest Estate 2001 Black Currant Ambrosia ($14.95) best sweet fruit wine of the show respectively. You must also try the cranberry wines, including the amazing Downey’s Estate 2002 Cranberry Ice ($22.95 per 375 ml), which is a real zinger!

For value, nothing can compare to two remarkably tasty, gold medal winning efforts recently launched by Magnotta. If you like pineapple juice, you will love Magnotta 2001 Pineapple Chardonnay at $5.95 Even better is Magnotta Blueberry Blue, which at a mere $6.95 tastes like fresh baked blueberry pie. Unfortunately, all the fruit wines mentioned are only available for sale at the wineries. Nor are they eligible for VQA designation. Surely the time has come for the LCBO to get a specialty fruit wine store functioning in say, St. Lawrence market. The store/tasting bar concept has worked perfectly in Montreal for many years now!

The trouble for most Ontario fruit wineries is that they are too small to knock on many licensee doors. It’s a chicken and egg situation where the restaurants refuse to order because “nobody asks for it.” Of course, if you don’t have it, you can’t sell it! It’s all too bad because these fruit wines would be perfect for Passover (such as the bronze winning Rodrigues Strawberry, which is Kosher) or Easter (one of the many delicious cranberry wines).

As for the best icewine you will have to rush to pick up the best of show sweet wine 2000 Riesling Icewine Limited Edition Merritt Road Vineyard (cspc 728253 - $39.95/375 ml) as only a few bottles remain at Vintages and winery stores. As for the best value sweet wine, make sure you try the Magnotta 2001 Vidal Select Late Harvest, which represents terrific mini icewine value at a modest $14.95/375 ml.

Ontario wines were also victorious in the white and red best of show classes. Don’t miss sampling Lakeview Cellars 2000 Chardonnay Reserve ($29.95) and Thomas & Vaughan 2000 Meritage ($24.95), which are only available from the wineries.

Finally, there is the best value white wine from South Africa - Fleur du Cap 2002 Chardonnay at $10.95 and the ever-delicious best value dessert wine Keo Commandaria St. John, a steal from the March 8th Vintages release. Its viscous, sweet but balanced, raisin pie flavours come with a lingering, refreshing fig and chocolate finish. It may well be the perfect thing to taste just prior to leaving the show. To see this year’s 192 Canadian International Wine Challenge (CIWC) winners Click Here.

The 20th Toronto Wine & Cheese Show continues today and is open Sunday noon to 6 pm at the International Centre (6900 Airport Road). Tickets are $15 per person - contact 416-229-2060 for information.

Coming up on Monday, April 14 is the 23rdannual California Wine Fair. This is largest tasting of California wines in Canada and is being held at The Fairmont Royal York - 100 Front Street West at 7:00 pm to 9:30 pm. Tickets are $50 for wine club members / $55 for invited guests. The afternoon trade-only event is for “invited guests of the liquor boards, media and hospitality industry only.” Trade identification is necessary to gain admittance. Call 1-800-558-2675 (CORK).

Competition Background  

 The Canadian International Wine Challenge is Canada’s largest competition where Canadian wines have a window to compete one-on-one with imports. A total of 468 wines were submitted in 17 classifications. There were 34 gold medals (7%), 60 silver medals (13%) and 98 bronze medals (21%). The wines were served blind in the appropriate classes in flights based on grape variety or fruit type. Also, this is the only competition in North America where award-winning fruit wines are professionally judged and then presented to more than 35,000 consumers. Only wines of merit receive an award. If, for instance, the wines in a specific class did not score sufficient points, no medal was awarded. Michael Vaughan, wine columnist at the National Post and editor of Vintage Assessments, led the judging. The judging panel included David Lawrason, Barbara Richie, Richard Feldkamp and Jay Fallah.

 

Vintages May 2003 Release
To see the complete list of upcoming products click here
(sorted by date of release). It includes the number of cases, which wines were presented by the LCBO, our agent ID for every product, as well as, special unannounced In Store Discoveries” for April.
You can also see it sorted by agent
click here  

 

Check out the
April 2003 InStore Discovery


Subscribe to Vintage Assessments Today
Click Here

 

Copyright Food & Beverage Testing Institute of Canada 2004
Prior written permission is required for any form of reproduction
 (electronic or other wise) and or quotation.
Contact Michael Vaughan at
mbv@total.net