July 18, 2008

REGISTER FOR
MICHAEL VAUGHAN'S

BUYING GUIDE

CLICK ON
THE NAME OF THE WINE

All recommendations are linked to the LCBO database enabling you to do an instant store search for current inventory.

Taster’s Diary
Inniskillin Winery Makeover • July 7
Shaw-Hillebrand-JT combo • July 13
Vintages July 19th Third Pretasting • July 15


Inniskillin Winery Makeover • July 7

It was a very long week. First there was the Inniskillin winery makeover launch. The group of mostly Toronto-based winewriters were picked up at the Royal York At 9 am. We squeezed into one of those long white limos and set sail. I remember the words sardine being quietly uttered by some passengers. No complaints from me - it was exactly what I had expected.

The first stop was the ultra-modern Jackson-Triggs winery for a tutored tasting of eight wines from the highly touted still unreleased 2007 vintage. Here two winemakers, one from JT (Marco Piccoli); the other from Inniskillin (Bruce Nicholson) presented two whites and reds respectively. Far be it for me to suggest, but it seemed as if that the guns were loaded for the JT wines. We tasted the following in Riedel tasting glasses:

2007 Vintage Barrel Sampling

White Wine Flight

1. Jackson-Triggs Delaine Vineyard Sauvignon Blanc *+/** out of three stars

2. Jackson-Triggs Delaine Vineyard Gewurztraminer **+/***

3. lnniskillin Winemaker's Series, Barrel Aged Pinot Gris ***

4. lnniskillin Winemaker's Series, Three Vineyard Chardonnay *+/**

Red Wine Flight

1. lnniskillin Winemaker's Series, Montague Vineyard Pinot Noir *+/**

2. lnniskillin Winemaker's Series, Montague Vineyard Merlot **/**+

3. Jackson-Triggs Delaine Vineyard Syrah ***

4. Jackson-Triggs Cabernet Franc
(destined to be Proprietors' Grand Reserve) ***

I was able to check the consistency of my tasting notes by bringing my own ISO glasses. They don’t necessarily make wines taste good, they just give me a level playing field with comparable tasting notes. Of the four whites, my favourite was the terrific still unreleased Inniskillin 2007 Barrel Aged Pinot Gris. It was a bit of an odd selection, because this Pinot Gris was a first for winemaker Bruce Nicholson. Challenging, but he did a great job! Meanwhile, the Inniskillin 2007 Winemaker’s Series Montague Vineyard Pinot Noir was a bit of an odd choice because this is not the final blend that will actually end up in the bottle. The Montague Vineyard is almost 100% Pinot Noir Clone 115 and lacks the diversity of flavours that can come with blending with other clones. We have to wait and see on this one. The two JT reds shown were big and mouthfilling, basically overwhelming the Inniskillin on show.

A hefty, multi-course lunch took place in the JT barrel cellar.  My white highlight was Jackson-Triggs 2007 Proprietor’s Reserve Sauvignon Blanc. It is fresh, crisp and very lively with ripe lemon-melon flavours along with tangy hints of yellow grapefruit.  

Moving over to the new Inniskillin winery, I experienced a totally new vision. The brand new airy Founders’ Hall has two sets of elegant wine bars. It is spacious and serves some food including a stunningly delicious homemade prosciutto made from locally-grown certified organic pigs, cured and dried in-house by Pingue Prosciutti (1-800-324-2998).  

I tasted it with a truly stunning yet-to-be-released Inniskillin 2007 Cabernet France Icewine. I crossed the new piazza to the fully renovated Braeburn barn. This is where most of the action takes place. The piazza inset with stones chronicling high points in Inniskillin's history, beginning with 1975. The first in the series says "Inniskillin established by Don Ziraldo and Karl Kaiser". It looks a bit like a cemetery marker. At 5:30 we returned to Toronto.

Shaw-Hillebrand-JT combo • Saturday, July 13

Given recent rave reviews, I wanted to see the just-opened Shaw production of The President. This one-hour, no intermission production started at 11:30 am. Given the idiosyncratic flow of traffic to and from Niagara, we decided to depart by 9 am. Our timing was perfect – we arrived by 10:30 am. If you had left Toronto at this time; it would have added an extra hour of driving.

The show was very humorous and hit the spot. The President’s machine-gun dialogue/dictation delivered with great gusto by Lorne Kennedy is loaded with laughs. Here is an extremely positive review from Richard Ouzunian - perhaps just a bit overly enthusiastic.

Lunch at the Hillebrand Winery Restaurant was terrific – a great, well-prepared menu and paired perfectly with the absolutely delicious well-priced 2007 whites. You can sit outside, but given the heat, a window seat was perfect. Frank Dodd has an excellent handle on local ingredients (to see the ever-changing menu click here).

The wine matches were really great. They have small flights of three that should not be missed. The Riesling Flight at $8 features three worthwhile examples: '07 Showcase, Trius '07 and Artist Series Semi Dry '06. The Aromatic Flight is also excellent with its Artist Series '06 Pinot Gris (terrific value), Artist Series '07 Sauvignon Blanc and award winning '07 Trius White.

It’s always nice to receive an invitation. It was my first Jackson-Triggs Twilight in the Vineyard concert in a number of years. Colin James was the entertainer of the night and tickets, which were sold out for the 8 pm show, fetched $64 plus $5 handling fee. I was informed that the show was completely sold out in two days!

I was also told that many attendees book the Vineyard Grill at the $105 (this becomes $119.78 with nary a drop of wine - a glass will set you back $5). One of the main reasons to get there early is to put down your lawn chair in one of the rows close to the stage (the gate opens at 5:30 pm). Be forewarned, a certain number of prime seats are reserved by JT for their special guests. 

The J-T website says this about the Vineyard Grill event: "Yes, you can have it all - gourmet cuisine, elegant wines, and the very best in entertainment! To add extra sparkle to a truly magical evening, guests are invited to enjoy the Vineyard Grille, an alfresco, picnic-style gourmet barbecue created by the renowned Jamie Kennedy Event Caterers - the perfect way to unwind on a warm summer’s evening. What better way to relax in the open air than with a gourmet meal inspired by nature..."

Winewriter Michael Pinkus, publisher/editor of Ontario Wine Review, is a regular attendee. He enjoys the shows, but is not singing hosannas about the JT food experience side of the equation. The season’s first event (the June 28th starring 54-40) wasn’t up to expectations: 'the caterers from Toronto’s Jamie Kennedy Kitchens showed up an hour late due to traffic issues… which prompted someone to remark, "couldn’t they find someone local?" Good question, considering that local cuisine is really beginning to take off in Niagara. After the almost an hour and fifteen minute wait (start time 6:00pm); dinner was derided as a disappointment by many at the Vineyard Grille … sure the french fries were very tasty, but the small hamburger, stale bun and over cooked tiny chicken breast was not worth the money to those who had paid fifty dollars for this meal. The best part of the dinner was the cold beat, bean and "local greens" salads, but you couldn’t make a meal out of them.' To see the entire Michael Pinkus article click here

I can’t comment on the BBQ because I went to the Cellar Dinner, a fairly boisterous, very pleasant affair, which is held in the cool barrel cellar. The cost is $160 for three courses plus pre-dinner cheeses and cucumber shooter. The
tax/gratuity total is $192.25. It is prepared by the local Good Earth Cooking School & Food Show (click here to see). Attendance is limited to 48 and tonight’s dinner is sold out.  The food is good; the smoked trout appetizer great.  There are a number of fine JT wines, all of which are showing well. I am sitting with a small group of enthusiastic local residents. I show them how the wine glass can totally change the way a wine tastes. I was surprised to discover that Cellar Dinner guests are not offered preferred seating. In fact, if you wish to get a glass of wine during intermission - well that's another $5. At $400 a couple, having to bring your own chairs, not getting any kind of reserved seating and being forced to line up to buy a glass of wine at intermission leaves something to be desired.

Vintages July 19th Third Pretasting • July 15

On Tuesday, I joined LCBO wine consultants in the LCBO lab to taste (for me a second time) some 90+ Vintages wines being released on Saturday, July 19. I ended up altering more than 50% of my notes – messaging scores up and down. There was only one serious disappointment De Sousa 2004 Reserve Pinot Noir (68148) at $17.95. The LCBO tasting note reads: Winemaker Andrzej (Andre) Lipinski has made an indelible mark on Niagara's wine scene over his storied career. He joined De Sousa in 2001 and quickly helped establish the winery's premium identity by developing its Reserve tier of wines. This sophisticated Pinot asserts Niagara's claim on the 'heartbreak grape'. It's dry, medium-bodied, with a smooth texture and layers of sour cherry and redcurrant flavours along with a smoky undertone and fine tannins. Tasted twice, I found this to be seriously disappointing. I rated it – out of three stars. Sadly, it has high VA (volatile acidity) - think of vinegar. In fact, it just squeaked in with1.2 g/l of acetic acid, just under the maximum limit of 1.3 g/l. My note: Ambering medium red colour. Spicy, dried green apple and pickle on the nose. Very tangy, dry, light bodied, pickle-tinged, red cherry vinaigrette flavours with a tart, slightly peppery, cedar-tinged finish.

Some recommendations for the release are:

Recommended • Best Buy
**+ (out of three stars)
Artesa 2006 Chardonnay
# 657585 • $21.95
Carneros
224 cases • 14.3% • Rus Woo

Light straw colour. Complex, spicy, buttery, key lime pie nose. Mature, medium-full bodied, vanilla and key lime pie flavours with a terrific lingering finish. Not for seafood, try with poultry and white meats. The 2001 (**/**+) was released on July 9, 2005 at $31.95. Unlike most of the California releases, the winery selling price ($20) is fairly close (within 10%) to the LCBO price. If Artesa can do it, why can’t the other wineries do it? Drinkability: { N S SM m }

Release Highlight • Best Buy
**+/*** (out of three stars)
Novas Winemaker's Selection 2006 Chardonnay/Marsanne/Viognier
# 63909 • $18.95
Casablanca Valley
200 cases • 14.5% • Lot: L80668 • Dia Est

This unique blend of Chardonnay, Marsanne and Viognier has a rather deep yellow colour. Aromas of orange citrus, apricot and jasmine - ver- spice like - with some mineral notes intermingled with elegant touches of mocha and toffee. Medium to medium-full bodied, well structured, complex, intense, spicy, key lime pie, apricot and ripe lemon flavours with a very long, lingering, buttery brioche and vanilla tinged finish. A great licensee pour with good acidity. Try with poultry, veal and perhaps lamb, but not with seafood. This organic wine contains 7 mg/L of free sulphur. Drinkability: { N S SM }

Recommended
**/**+ (out of three stars)
Palacios/Remondo 2005 La Montesa
# 674572 • $23.95
DOC Rioja
300 cases • 14% • Rus Woo

This blend of 40% Grenache, 45% Tempranillo and Graciano/Mazuelo was aged in French oak. Bright deep intense purple colour. Very juicy, plummy, slightly cedary, tropical fruit cocktail-tinged nose. Dry, medium bodied, well balanced, fairly spicy, gently juicy, ripe plum flavours with some dried black cherry notes on the lingering finish. An internationally-styled Rioja. Better than the 2004 (**) released on November 10, 2007 at $21.95. Drinkability: { N S SM M ml }

To get more best buys, become a FBTI supporter. You will receive my indispensable Vintages buying guide every two weeks for only $65.

 


July 5th Vintages Recommendation


The following are additional recommendations from the July 5th Vintages Release.

Whites
Canada
Recommended
**/**+
(out of three stars)
Flat Rock 2006 The Rusty Shed Chardonnay
# 43281 • $16.95
VQA Twenty Mile Bench
300 Cases • 9.1% • Fla Roc

This is Flat Rock’s top-tier Chardonnay. Light yellow colour. Intense, spicy, cedary, ripe lemon meringue nose. Intense, dry, very spicy, bright, medium bodied, well structured, ripe lemon meringue flavours with a lingering, cedary finish. Screwcap closure.

USA
Recommended
**+
(out of three stars)
Robert Mondavi 2005 Chardonnay
# 258186 • $29.95
Napa Valley
200 Cases • 13.5% • Chu Cel

Medium straw colour. Slightly spicy, attractive, ripe lemon-melon-lime nose with some honeyed, vanilla brioche notes. Dry, medium bodied, quite well structured, very bright, attractive, ripe lemon-lime flavours with a lingering vanilla tinged finish. The 2001 was released on September 18, 2004 at $29.95. It is readily available in the US for under $14 a bottle.

Australia
Recommended
**+/***
(out of three stars)
Devil's Lair 2005 Chardonnay
# 543447 • $39.95
Margaret River, Western Australia
300 Cases of 6 • 13.5% • Fos Win

Bright light yellow colour. Fairly intense, buttered toast, lemon meringue nose with some honeyed, custard-tinged, ripe pear notes. Very dry, bright, gently spicy, medium bodied, well structured, dried ripe pear flavours with some lemon-key lime pie notes on the long finish. Screwcap closure. Similar to the 2004 released on November 11, 2006 at the same price.

South Africa
Recommended • Best Buy
**/**+
(out of three stars)
KWV 2005 Cathedral Cellar Chardonnay
# 328559 • $14.95
WO Coastal Region
800 Cases • 14.5% • Lot: L8010 • Max Can

Bright, disarmingly deep yellow colour. Very intense, spicy, cedary, complex, ripe pear and lemon meringue nose. Dry, quite rich, spicy, medium bodied, well structured, cedary, ripe lemon-pear purée flavours with a lingering, caramel-tinged finish. Serve with white meats and poultry - not seafood. Terrific value and ready to enjoy.

Italy
Recommended
**
(out of three stars)
Pratello 2006 Catulliano Lugana
# 73411 • $15.95
150 Cases • 12.5% • Lot: L03.07 • Bas Inc

This 100% Trebiano di Lugana has a bright light yellow colour. Slightly honeyed, maturing, ripe lemon-apricot-melon nose. Dry, harmonious, medium to medium-light bodied, fairly fleshy, ripe lemon-melon-apple flavours with a lingering fairly tangy, unoaked finish. Versatile and ready. Made with organically grown grapes. This organic wine contains 33 mg/L of free sulphur, which is on the high side of the equation.

Reds
New Zealand
Recommended
**
(out of three stars)
Oyster Bay 2007 Merlot
# 692343 • $18.95
Hawkes Bay, North Island
644 Cases • 13.5% • Lot: 0658 L7340 • Max Can

Deep intense bright purple colour. Bright, gently juicy, ripe plum and black cherry nose. Dry, bright, medium bodied, dried black cherry and juicy plum flavours with a harmonious finish. Screwcap closure. Ready to enjoy.


Argentina
Recommended • Best Buy
*+/**
(out of three stars)
Septima 2006 Malbec
# 686113 • $15.95
Mendoza
500 Cases • 14% • Lot: L02808 • Rus Woo

Aged 6 months in American oak, this Malbec has a very deep intense purple colour. Fairly juicy, cedary, sweet blueberry and black cherry nose. Solid, dry, medium bodied, fairly well structured, spicy, juicy, black cherry flavours with a vanilla stick finish. At peak - try with BBQ ribs.


Portugal
Recommended
*+/**
(out of three stars)
Luis Soares Duarte 2005 Perfil Vinho Tinto
# 80424 • $18.95
DOC Douro
200 Cases • 13.5% • Eur Int

Very deep intense purple colour. Slightly cooked, dried ripe plum-cherry and red apple nose. Dry, harmonious, medium bodied, plummy, fairly juicy, red cherry flavours with a lingering, very slightly cedary finish.